What Is Bikeshedding and How Does It Impact The Workplace?

Have you ever found yourself in a meeting that drags on forever, discussing meaningless details while the big issues go untouched?

If so, you’ve encountered “bikeshedding,” meaning your team prioritizes minutiae over more meaningful matters. This can lead to ineffective meetings with widespread effects on the workplace.

Understanding bikeshedding can help you spot when you’re getting bogged down in trivial matters during team meetings or even while strategizing for social media. This sneaky issue can sap productivity, erode trust, increase worker burnout, and create inefficiencies across your organization.

So, let’s dive deep into bikeshedding, how it impacts your workplace, and how to avoid it.

Table of Contents

What Is Bikeshedding?

“Bikeshedding” is a term that refers to the phenomenon where people (especially in groups, teams, or organizations) focus disproportionately on trivial matters, often at the expense of more significant issues.

In a work environment, bikeshedding usually manifests when decision-makers or meeting participants concentrate on easy-to-grasp, non-essential issues. This can derail the purpose of the meeting and lead to an inefficient use of time and resources. Sometimes, these trivial matters can gain more attention than they warrant simply because they are easier to understand or discuss, shifting the focus away from what truly needs to be addressed.

The Origins of “Bikeshedding”

The term “bikeshedding” was inspired by Parkinson’s Law of Triviality, coined by British author C. Northcote Parkinson. The law was presented using the fictional example of a committee tasked with approving plans for a nuclear power plant. Instead of spending time on the intricate and critical aspects of the plant, the committee spent a disproportionate amount of time discussing the small details of a bikeshed meant for employee bicycles at the facility.

The story is a poignant illustration of how easy it is for groups to lose focus on significant, complex topics and become embroiled in trivialities. Parkinson’s observation was that the less important and simpler an issue is, the more discussion it generates. This is because trivial matters are easier to grasp and opine on, allowing more people to participate in the discussion, extending its duration and attention.

In this instance, the team knew very little about the nuclear power plant because it’s a complex and nuanced topic. They assumed the people in charge of “figuring it out” would understand how to do so. But the shed gave them a simple topic they knew enough about to discuss at length.

Think of it like the know-it-all in any group: because they know a lot about a topic, they hyperfocus on small details to display their knowledge. This often turns into people attempting to elevate themselves by finding errors or irregularities even when they don’t exist or don’t matter.

This origin story serves as a cautionary tale for modern workplaces. It underscores the need to be vigilant in meetings and decision-making processes, as it’s easy to get caught up in minor details and lose sight of the overarching goals and important agenda items.

How Bikeshedding Impacts the Workplace

Bikeshedding can appear in various forms in modern work environments, affecting team meetings and individual productivity. Whether it happens during a business meeting where the agenda includes a mixture of complex and straightforward issues or extends into project planning and workflow design, the results are often detrimental.

By understanding the various ways bikeshedding manifests and its far-reaching consequences, teams and organizations can better equip themselves to address this phenomenon. This can enable them to work towards improved productivity and more effective meeting strategies.

How Bikeshedding Manifests in the Workplace

Some of the most common ways bikeshedding manifests itself in the workplace are:

  • Meetings: Participants may focus on less significant matters like the presentation slide layouts, software tool choices, or break timing. If an hour meeting always takes 90 minutes, you might have a bikeshedding problem.
  • Project Planning: A team could spend excessive time deliberating on the colors and fonts for a new website, neglecting its usability and functionality.

Negative Impacts on the Workplace

Bikeshedding can create a domino effect that extends from meetings to the broader work environment. If not managed effectively, such consequences can negatively impact an organization.

Some of the most common negative impacts of bikeshedding on the workplace include:

  • Decline in Workplace Productivity: When trivial matters become the focus of discussions, the result is usually a lack of coherent strategy. This can cause a delay in project timelines and a decline in overall efficiency.
  • Ineffective Resource Utilization: The efficient and productive use of resources becomes compromised when teams focus on trivial tasks instead of prioritizing crucial tasks that need immediate attention.
  • Erosion of Trust and Collaboration: Persistent bikeshedding can erode trust among decision-makers and team members, leading to a culture of second-guessing and inefficiency.
  • Increased Stress and Frustration: The inefficiency of bikeshedding often leads to heightened stress and frustration among team members, potentially causing a negative environment—or worse, a toxic workplace.
  • Dilution of Leadership: Leaders who tolerate or engage in bikeshedding risk being perceived as less competent, undermining their ability to guide the team toward successful outcomes.

How to Overcome Bikeshedding in Meetings

Recognizing the detrimental effects of bikeshedding is only the first step. The real challenge lies in finding effective ways to counteract it.

By applying these strategies, teams and organizations can avoid becoming derailed during discussions and have more successful meetings. This can help teams leave the meeting with a clear game plan, reclaim wasted time and resources, and enhance overall productivity.

Here are some strategies to overcome bikeshedding and create a more focused, efficient, and collaborative work environment:

Establish Clear Objectives

Before entering any meeting or decision-making process, ensure the objectives are clear and well-articulated. By defining the purpose from the onset, you can steer conversations in a productive direction and reduce the likelihood of descending into trivial discussions.

Using meeting agenda templates can help you get started!

Set a Time Limit

Setting a time limit for each agenda item can be an effective strategy to keep discussions focused. It encourages participants to prioritize significant topics and helps them avoid getting stuck on minutiae.

Following your time limit and respecting your team’s time can help foster engagement, participation, and trust. Like I always say, “Start on time, end on time.”

Designate a Facilitator

A designated facilitator can help guide the meeting and keep the team on track. The facilitator’s role includes gently steering discussions away from trivialities and towards the meeting’s objectives.

Prioritize Issues

Make use of tools like the Eisenhower Box to prioritize issues. The Eisenhower box helps prioritize tasks by dividing them into categories like “Do,” Decide,” Delegate,” and “Delete,” Further classifying tasks into categories like “urgent and important,” “important but not urgent,” etc., can help teams discern what truly needs attention.

Let Your Team Use Their Voices

Promoting a culture where people feel safe to speak their minds can minimize the potential for bikeshedding. When team members feel heard, they are more likely to engage in meaningful discussions about complex issues rather than defaulting to simpler, less significant topics.

Foster Accountability

Establishing a culture of accountability can discourage bikeshedding by making participants more mindful of the quality of their contributions to discussions. Regularly review and measure the effectiveness of meetings to make continual improvements.

You might also consider offering recognition and rewards to those who make high-quality contributions to the meeting to reinforce staying on topic and accountable.

Provide Training

Training sessions focusing on effective communication and decision-making skills can give employees the tools they need to resist the lure of bikeshedding and engage in more productive dialogue.

Need help Prioritizing?

Explore ways to get Traction in your business.